COMMENTS:
-
"Rupert Murdoch --- he's the man of 2007. He had a Big Dream -- becoming the baron of business news, buying the Wall Street Journal and Dow Jones, and
launching the Fox Business Network all this year. He made it happen, despite challenges that would have deterred almost any other human being.
"But I'm also nominating NBC's Ben Silverman as a contender for Media Person of 2008. He already practically gave birth to reality TV, and I predict a
positive ratings reversal at his home network."
Bonnie Fuller, American Media, (2003 Media Person of the Year)
-
"I'll agree with Arianna and second Mark Zuckerberg. No one has prompted more discussion and excitement (and competitive derision) in media circles. There's no question that Google and Rupert are more powerful and influential, but Zuckerberg gets full marks for seemingly knowing and having things that both covet, and creating a brand/utility/whatever that is weirdly powerful and surprisingly broad. Unlike the other titans in the running, history would suggest that the chances of Zuckerberg topping the list next year or the year after that are against him, but he gets my vote for shaking up the here and now."
Richard Siklos, Fortune
-
"I give the nod to Mark Zuckerberg and Facebook -- and not just because he had the huevos to turn down $1 billion from Yahoo! Murdoch expanded his media reach and Google continues to gobble up the online universe, but Zuckerberg and his social networking baby were able to pull off a rare quinella: entering the Establishment's Zone of Respectability while retaining the patina of hipness. In 2007, Facebook was simultaneously cool enough for my 16 and 18-year old daughters and safe enough for ABC and Microsoft to get into business with it, and a mogul like Barry Diller to have a page there.
"Sea Change Moment: In January at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Zuckerberg was addressing a small group of media players from around the world. At one point, fellow Media Person of the Year nominee Arthur Sulzberger Jr. raised his hand and asked the 23-year-old Facebook founder, 'How do we improve our community at the New York Times?' 'You have no community,' replied Zuckerberg, without a hint of malice. Next question?"
Arianna Huffington, The Huffington Post
-
"Rupert Murdoch, for understanding the economics of media in a digital era with remarkably intuitive clarity. To my mind his plan to make WSJ.com free and open to all, trading limited direct revenues for maximum reach, marks the end of a decades debate over media business models online. Open beat closed and free beats paid, and if you're not part of the wider conversation on the Web you might as well not exist for the generation that's growing up online. Murdoch gets this, and it will be fascinating to see what the owner of MySpace will do to build social media into WSJ.com, turning its readership into a business community."
Chris Anderson, Wired
-
"Hearst Magazines president Cathie Black had an incredible 2007, with her unit seemingly the most desirable magazine company to work for (Hearst Tower helps) and her book, 'Basic Black,' winning acclaim. If there would be an 'un-Media Person of the Year,' I would nominate Howard Stern, whose Sirius deal made him very rich, but -- except to his die-hard fans -- very forgotten, because satellite radio does not yet have mass appeal. Will Stern and his lewdness go the way of Andrew Dice Clay?"
Steve Cohn, Media Industry Newsletter
-
"Rupert Murdoch: He didn't overpay for America's most influential brand in business journalism just to pump more money into it and preserve the status quo. Once a game changer, always a game changer."
Frank Rich, New York Times
-
"Google. Rupert Murdoch's a close second, but his big plays this year have seemed driven more by vanity and hubris than shrewdness -- the Fox business channel will fail, and while he may well make the Journal better, the paper will not in his lifetime (or probably ever) overtake the New York Times as the global paper of record, or justify the price he paid for it. Murdoch's the Media Person of the Decade, but that decade was the 1990s, when the Fox Network came of age, Fox News launched, and he brought News Corp. back from the brink of ruin. Murdoch is a hundred times more interesting than Sergey Brin and Larry Page, but Google's plan for world domination is just getting started."
Kurt Andersen
-
"I'll think a bit more, but I might figure it's the emerging coalitions of investigative reporters -- Center for Media and Democracy, Sunlight Foundation, Consumers Union -- dedicated to exposing the front groups that specialize in disinformation/scams online. (I've joined the boards of the last two organizations.)
Their long-term effects might be huge, starting with the November elections.
"Of course, there's also Jimmy Wales. It used to be that the powerful got to write history and shape our ideas. Now, everyone has a chance to participate with Wikipedia. It's also doing a good job building the means to deal with disinformation. All of this is led by Jimmy Wales, in a way that might change all media."
Craig Newmark, Craigslist
-
"The Media Person of the Year is Jon Friedman. If Time could get away last year with naming 'You,' then it stands to reason that I can name 'Me.' "
Jon Friedman, MarketWatch
-
"Steve Jobs the iPhone, for again expanding and linking media with technology in a unique format. Or, Rafat Ali, publisher of paidcontent.org, the Perez Hilton of the new media news space."
Cyndi Schoenbrun, Consumer Reports
-
"Bill Falk, unsung editor of The Week, which is the fastest growing weekly in America. Quietly puts out one of the smartest magazines around that proved there is intelligent life in the universe."
Tina Brown
-
"Rupert Murdoch is a formidable contender, but my vote would go to Google. The company is a disruptive force in nearly every media industry. They have a 60 percent global market share in search. With their purchase of DoubleClick in April, Google will be a dominant force in online advertising. They dominate user generated video content with their ownership of YouTube. With 'cloud computing' and the Apps Google crafts, they menace Microsoft. With their vow to create a free operating system for mobile phones, AT&T and Verizon execs have probably had a few sleepless nights."
Ken Auletta, The New Yorker
-
"Rupert Murdoch, no contest. He makes news, he buys newspapers. He's old media (WSJ); he's new media (MySpace). Murdoch launched a business news channel and has made enough news to fill its airwaves for months to come."
David Carr, New York Times
-
"My choice: Mona Shaw, the 75-year-old retiree who went 'Com-smash-tic' at her local Comcast cable office, busting up computers and telephones with a hammer out of frustration over poor customer service. My runner-up: Reuters reporter Robert MacMillan, who braved strong-arming by security guards while attempting to interview Rupert Murdoch at Dow Jones's offices. No, seriously, it's Rupert Murdoch, hands down. Buying Dow Jones and launching Fox Business Network in the same year is no small feat."
Patrick Phillips, I Want Media